Joe Abercrombie announces new novel - The Heroes

Thursday, August 27, 2009

Big news!

After his recent release of Best Served Cold, I thought it would take a long time to know what was coming in the future for Joe Abercrombie. Well, it didn't take long. Joe posted this on his blog today:

'With Best Served Cold already three months out (can it really be so long?), perhaps the time has come to talk a little about my next book. Like Best Served Cold it's intended to be a semi-standalone, which can be read on its own (hopefully) but has a few characters and settings in common with the First Law.

It is called:

The Heroes

Both because the action centres around a ring of standing stones called the Heroes, and because it's about heroism and that (meant semi-ironically, of course). It mostly takes place over the course of three days, and is the story of a single battle for control of the North. Think Lord of the Rings meets A Bridge Too Far, with a sprinkling of Band of Brothers and Generation Kill. It's about war, you get me? Principally it follows the (mis)adventures of six assorted persons on both sides and different levels of command, whose paths intersect during the course of the battle in various fateful, horrible, wonderful, surprisingly violent, surprisingly unviolent, and hilarious ways. With the Northmen: a veteran losing his nerve who just wants to keep his crew alive, an ex-Prince determined to claw his way back to power by any means necessary, a young lad determined to win a place in the songs for himself. With the Union: A depressive swordsman who used to be the king's bodyguard, a profiteering standard-bearer, and the venomously ambitious daughter of the Marshal in command. But of course a fair few familiar faces show up on both sides...'

He also mentioned that has already 85 000 words written so far. The book is expected to be release in February 2011 ('hopefully' as he put it).

I think it's really a good idea to continue with another "stand-alone" novel set in the same world, with new characters and old faces. The recipe worked great with BSC and I'm sure he can pull it off a couple more times. Although I think it will be kind of hard to center the story around a three day battle... but then, with what Joe showed us so far, the characters will probably make us want even more.

You can find the post on his blog here.

The Republic of Thieves prologue

Scott Lynch The Republic of Thieves prologue
Scott Lynch was feeling generous today. He updated his excerpts page with pages and pages of new goodies!

Scott Lynch The Republic of Thieves prologue
First he put a 40 000 words excerpt of Red Seas Under Red Skies... now we're talking! You want more? He even added notes about some elements. I really have to read that book soon. From what I gather it's a little notch less engaging as The Lies of Locke Lamora but totally worth the time. By the way, Scott also mentioned that he will add the same kind of excerpt for TLoLL.

Finally, he added the prologue for The Republic of Thieves, the third entry in the Gentleman Bastard sequence (that will hopefully be out next year, still no confirmation about that, but then I'm still one book behind so he can take his time!). You can finally be introduced to Sabetha!

Scott Lynch The Republic of Thieves prologue
You can find the links below!

Lynch post about the excerpts

The Republic of Thieves prologue and Red Seas Under Red Skies excerpt

Living in a fantasy world

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

I took part in the latest edition of "Inside the Blogosphere" by John at Grasping for the wind.

The question was "If you could live in an SF/Fantasy/Horror world, in which one would you live? Why?"

My choice was the Malaz world by Steven Erikson and Ian C. Esslemont (followed closely by Opelon from Elantris by Brandon Sanderson). You can read my full answer and the numerous replies from other SFF bloggers at John's blog. It's an interesting read. Here's the links :

Part 1
Part 2 ... mine is there :)

I also added the blog to my blogroll.

Hail to the Royal Mail

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

I received a nice little package today, directly from the UK! As soon as I finish Nights of Villjamur, I'll sink my teeth into the ninth opus of The Malazan Book of the Fallen. Dust of Dreams is another big door-stopper!


In other news, John at Grasping for the wind posted the SF/F/H Reviewer Linkup Meme, 2nd Edition. I won't post the full list but you can have a look here.



Peter V. Brett signaled on his website that the Desert Spear rewrite is finished. Also, if you're a fan of covers, one of Brett's fan sent him a nice cover he designed for The Painted Man (Warded Man).

Finally, George R.R. Martin posted on his "Not a blog" more casting choices for the HBO adaptation of ASoIaF.

Personal news now....I'm moving to my new house in two days... so I don't think I'll have the time to post anything for a couple of days. I almost finished Elantris and I'll post the review when I'm finally installed! Wish me luck! For now, I return to my game of Fat Princess :)


Best Served Cold review

Thursday, August 20, 2009

Best Served Cold review Joe Abercrombie
Best Served Cold review Joe Abercrombie
Best Served Cold and its author, Joe Abercrombie don't need much presentation. The hype surrounding this book was pretty high and the reviews so far very positive. I enjoyed Abercrombie's The First Law trilogy (it's in my list of reviews to add to the blog), so I couldn't wait any longer for the North American release and I ordered my copy from the UK.

As the title suggest, this book is about vengeance. This is the years of blood in Styria and the mercenaries are getting rich. We follow the story of The Thousand Swords mercenary army leader Monzcarro Murcatto (everyone calls her Monza) on her vengeful quest to punish those who tried to kill her and her brother. After an unlikely recovery weakening her, she will soon discover that to kill these seven people, Monza's going to need allies to have any chance of success. Her path will meet with Shivers, a north man looking for a good man life in Styria (he was seen in The First Law trilogy), Castor Morveer, a loquacious master poisoner and his young apprentice Day, ex practical Shylo Vitari, Nicomo Cosca, 'famed soldier of fortune' and drunkard (the last two from The First Law again) and Friendly, a liberated convict bodyguard obsessed with numbers. She will travel all over Styria within the League of Eight with Duke Orso's head hunters at her back.

I was pleased to see that Best Served Cold reintroduced many characters from The First Law trilogy. Because of this, to fully enjoy Best Served Cold, I think you really need to read The First Law before, it will give you a better experience. Along with the main protagonists, there are some really nice cameos.

Let's shake off the somewhat negative aspect first. During the reading, I had some problems with Monza narrative. At times, you really don't feel like she deserves to get her revenge and it gets a little uncomfortable as she's the main protagonist. This probably didn't make it easy for Abercrombie while writing. There are some pretty hard chapters (when Shivers and her tell each other their plain truths) but it's understandable in a rough setting as this. But eventually, everything comes nicely together and you'll cherish all the main PoV. Best Served Cold was compared to Kill Bill in some reviews... I think it's probably an easy comparison because it's about a girl taking her vengeance but not a perfect analogy.

The only other annoying element for me was that the story had a little tendency to drag between each "killing sub plot". I feared that a book this long centered around a vengeance would be repetitive, but every time, everything got back on track. The book is separated in parts with each person to kill and it feels almost as if it was seven short stories. It gets more complicated as things evolve and in the long run, it feels epic in scale, which is a good thing (you can feel the Gurkish and Union influences in the conflict too).

Abercrombie's writing is as good as ever if not even better. I like the way he's able tell a tale this dark and serious while adding a nice layer of humor, I could even say plenty of it. There's still swearing and gore and sex but Joe really found a way of masterfully integrating all these elements in his writing just the right way. Speaking of those moments, he went even farther that in The First Law with Best Served Cold. I would like to add Kick-ass moments to my blog with some of this book scenes but I'm not sure it belongs to the web. :) The action sequences are really well rendered.

As far as the writing goes, the best part of it is the characterization. Besides what I mentioned about Monza, every characters (even the secondary ones) are a delight, they don't feel like clichés to me. Morveer's way of talking, especially with the not so learned Shivers is a real joy. Cosca is probably the most pleasurable. A lot of PoV are used, but the author returns more often with Shivers and Monza.

I won't comment much on the magic system since it's not important and not necessary in the book. Don't worry, it's still a fantasy novel. Some of the protagonists who can appear from dead air and others are exceptionally powerful (remember the eaters?). The world-building is quite satisfying. Since everybody Monza wants dead are in different part of Styria, we get to travel a lot of ground. Each city has her own characteristics and I could easily imagine myself walking the streets.

Little detail, I really think that Abercrombie's way of naming his chapters is a great asset, as are his "parts" quotes and Monza's past introductions.

Why should you read this book? Well if the review is not enough, I can tell you that Best Served Cold is a strikingly well written, humorous, gritty, sexy, darkly and unforgiving piece of work. You just can't pass over this one. The characters will totally compel you to follow them.

Technically, I think the Gollancz cover is beautiful and way better than the US Orbit cover with the bloodied girl. There's no complete map in the book but every book section start with a quote and in the background there's a map of the city area involved. The cover also shows the map in the background but for a clearer version you can go here. There is no appendix/glossary. The book is 534 pages.

Best Served Cold review score :

Characterization............. 9 /10
World building............... 8.5 / 10
Magic system................. N/ A
Story.............................. 8.5 / 10
Writing........................... 9.5 / 10

Overall (not an average) 9 / 10

Enjoy!

Joe Abercrombie page

Stephen Deas Interview

Sunday, August 16, 2009

Stephen Deas interview
Here is an interview I did with Stephen Deas, author of The Adamantine Palace released earlier this year (look for my review of The Adamantine Palace and Stephen website here).

From what I gathered from his answers, the follow-up to his dragon centered series, King of the Crags, seems even more interesting. He is also working on a new series about which he is giving us some details.

I asked him about some of his kick-ass moments and I was pleased to see that he chose one of the moments I mentioned in my first kick-ass post.

Now let's put the spotlight on the author, here's the interview :

First, can you briefly introduce yourself and describe your book?

Hi everybody. My name's Stephen Deas and I'm the author of The Adamantine Palace. I live in southeast England and most mornings I get up and go to work like everybody else. I'm six foot four, I have size ten feet.... What? I can tell you more... no? Oh, right. Writing then. What can I tell you about The Adamantine Palace?

It's mostly green. A sort of dark Jaguar racing green. With a dragon on it. Except in France where it's mostly yellow with an even bigger dragon on it. It's the first part of a trilogy of books set in a world filled with dragons that used to be wild and intelligent creatures but have been tamed and made stupid by alchemy. The first book pays very little attention to how all this came about (that comes later) and splits its time between two facets of the world: the intrigues and politics of the dragon-kings and queens as they vie to become the ruler of The Adamantine Palace; and the story of a single dragon and who (with her handler) becomes lost during a skirmish and begins to wake up out of her alchemical stupor. And she is NOT happy.

If you want a five word summary of the way the story is written, well then I agree with you that it's probably what's written on the front of the book, “A fast, sharp ruthless read.” It sets off at speed and doesn't stop. There's fights, murders, poisonings, seductions, betrayals, everything short of open warfare all going on at once and yet I'd say, in the end, it's the dragons that steal the show. When they wake up, they kick ass. That's book one. It's very action-centred start to the trilogy.

Stephen Deas interview
From your point of view, is it a story mainly about the dragons themselves and their impact or about the people living in this dragon inhabited world governed by a ruling class fighting a deadly game of political intrigue?

First and foremost a story needs to be about people. It has to be centred around characters with whom a reader can identify, empathise, or at least understand. You can make dragons be like people to achieve that and many writers have followed that path. I've tried not to do that, although I know from comments I've received that a lot of people sympathise with Snow. I wonder how true that will be after book two.

Having said that, I think the story is very much about the impact that dragons have on the people around them, although perhaps not in the most obvious ways. Yes, they can burn cities and eat villages and still be hungry, but I'm thinking more about what it's like to live in a world where you have these monsters at your beck and call – and to always know they're only a few un-drugged weeks away from razing your entire world to the ground. Hell, they're so big and powerful that people regularly die by accident just because either they or a dragon got careless. An idle flick of the tail? Dead. Too close when a dragon flaps its wings? Dead. Dragon sneeze? Dead (although I'm not sure that dragons actually sneeze). To me, a lot of the trilogy is about the people who are close to the dragons and how they are affected by it rather than the dragons themselves. There are the dragon-riders, the Jehals and Zafirs, the Shezira's and Hyram's for whom dragons are tools and weapons. These are two forceful and impulsive characters who act decisively and tend not to reflect on what they are doing very much. I see that sort of personality as an almost necessary result of having these monsters at your beck and call. If you start to think about it all too much, wouldn't you simply be over-awed? Wouldn't you curl up in a corner and whimper? And what sort of king does that? Then you have the alchemists, whose duty above all else is to keep the dragons under control. They're the ones who really understand how easily everything could go wrong and how terrible that could be. So they tend to an opposite trait, always thinking and planning and trying to maintain the status quo. There are the Adamantine Men, who are trained (indoctrinated) from birth to die in their thousands fighting dragons if the need arises. There are the Outsiders like Sollos and Kemir, who see their homes destroyed by men on dragon-back. So yes, for all the intrigues and so forth, the heart of the trilogy is centred around what it means to live with these almost impossibly dangerous creatures permanently around.

Joe Abercrombie’s comment printed on the book is "A fast, sharp, ruthless read". I must agree with him about the fast pace of the book. Do you think this pace (and the short chapters) was better suited for the story or is it you usual writing “style”?

The nature of the dragons dictated the pace. They are a force of nature (or something... more of that in later books), remorseless, relentless and unstoppable and I wanted that to be reflected even in the prose itself. My usual style is still fairly fast – I like a story to get on with itself and not muck about – and in The Adamantine Palace, this was deliberately exaggerated. I realise this doesn't suit all tastes; the pace certainly comes at a price – what you get to see is the surface of the world these characters live in and you get to see the surface of the characters themselves, but you don't get to see much beneath either. Whatever hidden depths they may have, they're for later. Things slow down (a bit) in book two to give a little more time and depth to some of the characters and the history of the world. There was a lot I had to leave out of The Adamantine Palace that I simply can't put aside in the remainder of the story.

You already explained in a previous interview (http://www.sfbok.se/fantazin/fanfeature.asp?strIntervju=Stephen Deas) why you chose to write in a fantasy setting and why you chose dragons as a main theme. Dragons have been used a lot in fantasy. What would you say to a reader who is hesitant to pick up the book since it’s about dragons?

Depends why they're hesitant. These are old-school pre-Pern monsters. If you're hesitant because you don't like the way dragons have become flying ponies or have developed characters that are hard to distinguish from the humans around them, well then you might want to give my dragons a try. If you simply don't like dragons, try thinking of them as a metaphor for nuclear weapons or religious extremism or whatever else keeps you up at night worrying that the world is teetering on the brink of destruction and then read the answer a couple of questions above. If you still don't like dragons then, well, maybe you're right to hesitate. It's got some sex in it... does that help?

Which character(s) from The Adamantine Palace do you mostly like to write about?

My favourite character across the whole trilogy is the Night Watchman, but he doesn't even appear in book one. As far as the first book goes, I had most fun with the two mercenaries Sollos and Kemir when they were together. Their bickering banter was some easy fun. I've enjoyed writing Jehal too. I'd loathe him if we met in person, but I happen to know there's more to him than the smug, superficial scheming bastard he appears to be (alright, maybe not much, but he does have some demons). I also get to decide what happens to him...

You don’t seem to be afraid to kill some important PoV. Without naming them, do you think you’ll miss some of them?

Yes. One in particular. Not only do I miss writing their scenes, they were handy to the plot, too. In fact, if they hadn't gotten themselves killed, the whole story might have been different...

Can you give us more detail about the upcoming books of the trilogy (The King of the Crags and the final book)?

A little. OK, the basics. The second book is called The King of the Crags and, last I heard, will be published in the UK in April 2010. I'll be getting on with the editorial re-writes right after I've finished answering these questions. The second book picks up the action where the first one left off and weaves in a bit more of the world's history as best it can without sacrificing the pace. As you can imagine, if you've read the first book, there are a plenty of people who aren't going to be happy with the way things have turned out and they're planning on doing something about it. The Taiytakei are still up to something. There are some new characters, even a couple with some sort of moral compass that makes them almost the 'good guys', although I'm sure they'll get eaten at some point. There's a lot more about alchemists, of how their order came to be and how it works. There will be more dragons. I can promise at least one mass battle. You'll get to see another side of some of the events in The Adamantine Palace from a viewpoint that's a little more thoughtful than most of the characters in book one.

I'm not going to say much about book three except that it will have dragons in it. Lots of dragons. And someone will manage to kill one without poisoning it in its sleep at least once. It's already written; although it needs quite a bit of rework, the ending, I think, will stay the same.

Any plan on putting a detailed map on the following books?

Ah, maps. I like maps, but the short answer is no, there will be no map in any of the dragon books. What I'm going to do is put a map up online. This has a couple of advantages – firstly you can view it at whatever size you like. Secondly I mean to make it a fully hyperlinked gazetteer, so you can click on a place on the map and find out more about its history and features. At the rate things are going, the gazetteer project will be the size of a small novel. Want to know about the Yamuna[1] river that gets mentioned once in book three? Want to know about the people who live there and the giant boat-swallowing worms that never get mentioned at all? All in the gazetteer. So for people who really like all that sort of world-building detail, you can, if you want to, just look up any place mentioned in the story and find out more. For those who only want the bare minimum of the world to keep the story going, you can ignore it. Best of both worlds? Possibly. An experiment? Definitely.

My hand-drawn draft is already available at http://www.stephendeas.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/low-rez-map.pdf and the rest will be all sorted out by the end of this year. Feedback will be very welcome once it starts going up in the autumn.

Did you have the whole vision of the dragon trilogy before you started writing or did the story evolved as you wrote it? Same thing for Thief-Taker’s Apprentice?

A bit of both. While I give my characters a lot of latitude in how they find their way through the story I've designed for them, I wouldn't put finger to keyboard without knowing how that story was going to end and at least roughly how to get there. I don't think I'd be allowed to either. I'm expected to produce a synopsis, even if only a half a page, for each book I've been asked to write and I don't think I'd have been offered a publishing contract without being able to show I have a complete vision with a coherent outline and a definite end. I think you'll find this is fairly normal. That said, there's a lot of empty story-space to be filled between a synopsis and a novel. Characters often evolve and take on a life of their own, and sometimes the story has to bend to accommodate that.

I rate the books I review by Characterization/World building/Magic system/Story/Writing and general feeling. Are any of these aspects more important in your case when you write?

Characterisation, definitely, although all these terms are open to interpretation. Stories are about people and if the people aren't credible then the story won't be credible. Doesn't matter whether it's a fantasy, a thriller or a romance, you have to get the basics of character right. Everyone has to have their own internal consistency. After that, you have to have a story. No matter how good the writing and the world-building, somewhere in there I think you have to have a working story. After that, well, what does world-building mean? Does that mean a very detailed fictional world, even if its presentation is dry, detached and dull? Does it mean a real sense of immersion into the fantasy world, even if the details, when you look at them, are few and far between? Somewhere in between? What does 'writing' mean? Is that how easy it is to read? Is it about pace? About descriptions? I think these are terms that will have different meanings to different people. To me, what matters is that a story pulls you in and carries you with it to the end. There are lots of ways of doing that, and that's one of the pleasures of reading, to find yourself being drawn into different stories in entirely different ways.

You wrote on you website that you are working on a new series, the first book being named Thief-Taker’s Apprentice. What will this new series be about?

This is the story of an orphan street-boy, Berren, who makes the big mistake of trying to cut a thief-taker's purse. Instead of handing him over to the guard for a quick whipping, the thief-taker gives Berren the choice to work for him instead. It's an attractive proposition for a boy with nothing to lose, and it offers him an easy escape from his past to something that seems infinitely better. Trouble is, while it gets Berren away from his own past, it puts him right in the path of the thief-taker's history, once it starts to catch up with him. A past that includes a company of mercenaries led by a de-throned prince, a collection of extremely dubious magicians and a rather nasty knife. It's quite different in its approach as compared to The Adamantine Palace, in that the action largely takes place in one city and the point of view remains almost entirely with Berren. It's a smaller story in most senses of the word and that gives it a bit more time to dwell on its characters and location. Before you ask, there's no overt connection between this story and The Adamantine Palace; the astute reader, however, may recognise one or two common points of reference.

Will you ever write something outside of fantasy?

I have already and will/would again, although maybe that depends on where you draw the line that defines 'fantasy.' I've dabbled with science fiction (are The Cloud Atlas and The Time Traveller's Wife science fiction? If they're not then I've dabbled with something else). I've dabbled with horror. I have a story waiting to be written that's about a man trying to cope with the unexpected and seemingly random death of his daughter (not a situation I've ever been in – don't ask me where this comes from). I could sit down and write any one of three or four stories right now and only half of them would be fantasy. For the foreseeable future, though, what I write is dictated by what I'm contracted to write, which is fantasy, and whatever time I have left over afterwards, which is absolutely none at all at the moment. In my perfect world, I would probably be writing at least three different and largely unrelated stories all at once. At the moment that would mean pretending I don't have a family, but if ever I have more time then yes, the stories are there and so is the will to write them.

What book(s) would you recommend to your readers?

When it comes to fantasy, I'm a Conan fan. Read the Conan stories. Read the Deed of Paksenarrion by Elizabeth Moon. Read Joe Abercrombie. All character-centred, action-driven stories. Read early KJ Parker, too. Outside fantasy, I'd recommend Hyperion by Dan Simmons, The Neutronium Alchemist by Peter Hamilton. Quicksilver by Neal Stephenson is as much a history book as a novel and utterly fascinating and most of his other works are well worth a look. Jane Austen isn't one of the most widely read writers in the world for no reason. Joseph Conrad is hard work but has been worth it so far. I'm trying to think of hidden gems here now and the sad truth is that I'm lucky if I get to read more than half a dozen books a year at the moment. Also I seem to have moved to recommending books that I like rather than ones that have anything much in common with what I actually write. I've noticed that any book called The Of The Wind seems to be a good bet. And do I really need to mention A Game of Thrones?

I put a couple of “kick ass moments” (a memorable scene, a funny dialogue, a great sentence) on my blog. Do you have a “kick ass moment” you remember from what you’ve read before that you could share with us?

There are a lot of kick-ass moments in Snowcrash. The ending of the second book of the Deed of Paksenarrion (I shalln't say what, but I went off sick the next day so I could go and buy and read the last book, which is something that hasn't happened all that often). When Tyrion Lannister finally has enough of his dad. “It turned out that the stories were wrong and Tywin Lannister didn't shit gold after all.” Or something like that.

There seems to be an increasing number of fantasy writers who are adding more sex/gore/violence/ swearing to their books. We also see less of the farming boy with the great destiny and the “righteous good” vs. “vicious evil”. I think The Adamantine Palace belongs to this new tendency in fantasy. What do you think of this new approach to fantasy?

Much the same as I think of my 'new' approach to dragons – that it isn't new at all. We live in more explicit times, with regard to sex and violence and swearing and this 'new' fantasy reflects that. In the context of their times, though, I think the fantasy of the twenties and thirties wasn't all that different; Joe Abercrombie's works, which I'm sure fall into this 'new' category, remind me somewhat of very old and traditional viking romances – which is great, but not 'new.' What has happened, I think, is that the 'farm-boy-with-a-great-destiny' and the whole 'righteous good vs. vicious evil' black and white morality has gone away (I'm not so sure how prevalent it ever was, but there are some very large and successful examples of that sort of fantasy. Star Wars, for example). I suspect that reflects the more morally ambiguous times we live in. In that respect, maybe fantasy has finally caught up with the fact that the Berlin Wall isn't there anymore and we've moved back into a period of history where there isn't a great 'Evil Empire' that we're all supposed to be afraid of overthrow. I could add that role-playing games probably have something to do with it too.

[1] Not to be confused with the real Yamuna river that runs past the Taj Mahal and is, to my knowledge, free of boat-eating giant worms.

Seven Kingdoms Map

Saturday, August 15, 2009

It seems that maps will be my topic of the week. Adam at The Wertzone posted this news yesterday about a new gorgeous map. That's by far the best rendering of the Seven Kingdoms from A Song of Ice and Fire by George R.R. Martin. A treat for the maps lovers! Thanks Adam for the info! I hope they will also create a map this fine for the other part of Martin's world, the Lands of the Summer Sea.

This map was created by the guys at the Cartographer Guild, the same folks that I talked to you about when I posted the link for the "Northen Reaches of the Yhelteth Empire" map (from The Steel Remains by Richard Morgan).

I updated my index of maps.

A thousand visitors and new poll

Thursday, August 13, 2009

The blog reached a first little milestone today, a 1000 unique visitors! (with more than 1600 pageloads...) It's a start! I hope to be able to keep you coming, I love to share. There's so many more books to review out there.

I updated the blog link list with Davebrendon’s Fantasy & Sci-Fi Weblog. Interesting blog that I just discovered.

Finally, it seems that my last question was not very appealing with only 5 votes. With that nubmer, it's impossible to know what people are mostly looking for in a review. Now... for the next question :

Do you like to have maps in your fantasy books?

Me? If you have read my reviews it should be obvious... unquestionably yes! But they have to be well drawn which is usually the case. I know some people say that a map is a way of restricting our imagination when we read a book but then you can always avoid looking at it. I think that a map has exactly the opposing effect. When I look at a map, I can better place myself in the position of the character, so I feel it's more of a support for my imagination.

Toll the Hounds review

Tuesday, August 11, 2009



Toll the Hounds is Steven Erikson eighth book of the tale of the Malazan book of the fallen, which I read as soon as I received it last year. Since the follow up is coming soon , only 5 or 6 days, I did a little look-up of the last books (even if it's not a direct follow-up of Reaper's Gale story) to refresh my mind. So this is certainly the best time to add a review. Your humble servitor will probably try to add reviews of the whole series eventually. I won't lie to you, this is my favorite fantasy series so far and I think by far... so this is a review from a fan even if I try to stay objective as hard as I can.

The story picks up a couple of years after the events of Memories of Ice in our beloved city of Darujhistan, the city from the first book Garden of the Moon. There's a convergence coming and the city will be its host. At the same time, Cutter reunites with his former companions (Murillio, Kruppe, Coll, Rallick Nom and his old love interest Challice) while Barathol, Chaur and Scillara are meeting with ex-Malazan marines. Karsa, Kallor, Traveller, the hounds, Hood and the army he is gathering are drawn by it. The weight of Dragnipur on Anomander Rake's back is becoming unbearable. Inside the sword, the battle against the coming Chaos is looming close. Rake's son Nimander, Clip and the Drift Avalii escapees are coming home to Rake and encounter a new corrupted "false god". This god treathens to corrupt the newly named Redeemer who will need the help of Spinnock Durav, a Tiste Andii and his game companion, Seerdomin.

It's almost impossible to finish giving the details of the story since there's so much more characters (Mappo, Gruntle, OK I'll stop here) and plots. Although some PoV may seem of less interest, like the boy Harllo, it still has its uses with the advancement of the general narrative. The story is written with the same kind of pace that we saw in previous Malazan novels, meaning that a little more than a hundred pages before the end, the book becomes totally impossible to put down as the pace shift to the fastest gear. So much storylines are coming together or to a close! This is probably Erikson greatest mastery, the way he is able to pull the strings of so many plots and eventually connect them together in a mesmerizing spectacle.

I felt that the book is mostly about what people have to go throught and the price to pay for their redemption. Itkovian and his new cult and all the Tiste Andii subplots are examples of this (even Kallor). This is not the only theme, but it's the major one. We also see that with so many mighty forces, when an opportunity presents itself, the only result can be devastation.

As for the writing, it's Erikson at his best. I have to admit that the prose can get complicated sometimes... and as in the last few novels, I was annoyed to have almost only poems at the start of every chapter. In the first books, the chapters started with Malazan historical facts, famous quotes and from time to time a poem but in this book, it's a Fisher Kel Tath fest! It's not really lowering the quality of the writing but still, that's too much for my taste... I felt the same as when I read Tolkien songs.

I found that Kruppe chapters are slightly more complicated but satisfying in the end (I don't find them annoying). With his take on the story at the end of some chapters (almost in the perspective of Darujhistan), we can feel that the city is alive and get a refreshing insight on its inhabitants.

As always, there's a score of PoV and secondary characters, a proportion of them being highly captivating (mostly those in Black Coral). The Tiste Andii Spinnock Durav, the warrior of Anomander Rake and his new companion Seerdomin are great additions. Their storyline will take them to interact with the Redeemer, Itkovian. The other new Tiste Andii Pov, Endest Silann (Rake's old mage) is of less interest but when his turn come, we get to have great details about the Andii's past in Kharkanas. Anomander Rake is still one of my favorite characters and in this book he gets even more fascinating. Erikson mentioned that he wants to write a trilogy about Rake's past after the ten books of the Malazan book of the fallen!!!

The humor in the book is still present although maybe not as much as usual. The principal source of it is usually the Malazan marines and their lesser presence (don't worry there's still enough of them) in the book make for a slightly more serious book. The Tiste Andii storylines are way too nostalgic and tragic to add humor. At least, we can still follow the Shadowthrone\Cotillion duo and their mad high priest Iskaral Pust, Kruppe's insights and Karsa's comments with Samar Dev. By the way, I don't know if it's just me but sex is way more present than usual in this book (there's not that much sex but the subject is frequently on the table).

We don't learn much more about the already well establish complex magic system in this book but all the Dragnipur scenes and the Kharkanas flashbacks add even more depth to the mythology (which is already a gigantic realisation). We also get to see new parts of the Genabackis continent and the city of Black Coral. The world building is getting even more accomplished!

Why should you read this book? Because that's the best example of epic fantasy. This is an insanely large scale series but so much worth it. The writing is superb, and the world created so rich (this is mostly about the whole series). The multitude of great characters is crazy. For the Malazan fans, you should not even have to ask you whether to pick it up or not, the series is still going strong. The plots that are developed in this book are nicely evolving and it's great to come back to characters we love but that we haven't heard of in a long time. Bring on Dust of Dreams!

There are already two scenes in this book that I added to my "Kick ass moment" list (here and here) and I would have added a third but I don't want to spoil one of the funniest scene of the book, a mighty battle between two unlikely protagonists.

Technically, the Bantam Press cover is very nice (I think it's better than the Tor cover), like almost all the latest Malazan novels from Erikson. As usual, the maps are well drawn (a must for maps and Malazan lovers) and the appendix (Dramatis personae) can be kind of useful. The book is 896 pages... a door stopper as all of Erikson's Malazan books.

Characterization............. 9.5 /10
World building............... 10 / 10
Magic system................. 10 / 10
Story.............................. 9 / 10
Writing........................... 9 / 10

Overall (not an average) 9 / 10

Enjoy!

Malazan empire page

Kick ass moment #6

Monday, August 10, 2009

'I am sorry,' cut in Raest, 'is something happening?'
Antsy's eyes bulged slightly. 'The Hounds of Shadow are loose!'
Raest leaned forward as if to scan the vicinity, and then settled back once more. 'Not in my yard.'
Antsy clawed through his hair. 'Trust me, then, it's a bad night - now, if you'd just step back -'
'Although, come to think of it, I did have a visitor earlier this evening.'
'What? Oh, well, I'm happy for you, but -'
Raest lifted one desiccated hand and pointed.

Antsy and Barathol turned. And there, in the yard, there was a fresh mound of raw earth, steaming. Vines were visibly snaking over it. 'Gods below,' the Falari whispered, making a warding gesture with one hand.
'A T'lan Imass with odd legs,' said Raest. 'It seemed to harbour some dislike towards me.' The Jaghut paused. 'I can't imagine why.'
Antsy grunted. 'It should've stayed on the path.'
'What do T'lan Imass know of footpaths?' Raest asked. 'In any case, it's still too angry for a conversation.' Another pause. 'But there's time. Soldier, you have been remiss. I am therefore disinclined to yield the floor, as it were.'

'Like Hood I have!' And Antsy reached beneath his tunic and tugged out a bedraggled, half-rotted shape. 'I found you your damned white cat!'
'Oh, so you have. How sweet. In that case,' Raest edged back, 'do come in.'
Barathol hesitated. 'What will this achieve, Antsy?'

'He won't die,' the ex-sergeant replied. 'It's like time doesn't exist in there. Trust me. We can find us a proper healer tomorrow, or a month from now - it don't matter. S'long as he's breathing when we carry him across the threshold. So, come on, help me.' He then realized he was still clutching the dead cat, and so he went up to the Jaghut and thrust the ghastly thing into most welcoming arms.

'I shall call it Tufty,' said Raest.

[Raest, a Jaghut Tyrant (retired)]

Steven Erikson - Toll the Hounds

Kick ass moment #5

Update and news

Sunday, August 2, 2009

I don't have much time while on vacation to read or listen to my audio book but I will pick up the pace soon. Here are some updates on the blog and the news I found interesting lately.

I added a link to my list of reviews so far at the top of the right bar.

I will be posting interviews of some authors I wanted to make soon.

The news...


Jason at Dragonmount read and reviewed (here) The Gathering Storm, the next installment of The Wheel of Time written this time by Brandon Sanderson from Robert Jordan notes. As he mention himself, he's a real fan of Jordan's work and a friend of the family, so we have to take his point of view in perspective. It seems that the writing is more Sanderson style but he accurately portrayed many of the characters. And finally Rand will be the PoV for almost half of the book chapters, that should keep things interesting enough for my taste. He also note that one of the main protagonists doesn't have any chapters where he's the PoV. I hope it's Elaine (or even Nynaeve). I hate it so much when they can stop talking about men or when they make their deadly look with their eyes... it seems that every woman in WoT is capable of making people weep just by looking at them with their angry eyes :)

Update : Another tidbit about WoT, the video game adaptation (news by Kotaku) will be made by Chris Morgan, the writer of the movie The Fast and the Furious: Tokyo Drift... not sure if this good news...

Pat at the Fantasy Hotlist and Aidan at A Dribble of Ink posted news about new books coming up from Brian Ruckley (on his website) and Brandon Sanderson. Ruckley's new novel will be called Edinburgh Dead and will feature an alternate reality of the city. in the 19th century I don't usually like real world mixed up with fantasy, but as he mention himself, he writes fantasy so there will be a lot of "veteran warriors, magical conspiracies, killers both human and decidedly not". I still haven't read The Godless World trilogy but I expect great things to come. As for Sanderson's new series, it's named The Stormlight Archive and the first book is The Way of Kings. It should be at least four or five books. If you read the synopsis, it seems that Sanderson created again an amazing new world and magic system. That guy is unstoppable, we will have to call him Mr. Fantasy World Builder soon. I have read Mistborn and I'm listening to Elantris right now and I can say that Sanderson is swiftly making up his position on my favorite author list.

Update : I'm eagerly waiting for the Bauchelain and Korbal Broach omnibus by Steven Erikson and it seems that he's going to give us even more on these two necromancers. Pat posted this from the PS Publishing website, it's about Crack’d Pot Trail, Erikson new novella. Can't wait to read them all, Erikson si really a profusive writer!


Hollywood seems to be more and more interested in putting fantasy books to tv or even the big screen. Peter V. Brett book The Warded Man was optioned for a motion picture (it was announced previously here) and it will be directed by Paul W. S. Anderson. I have read the book and I think it should make a good movie. This is the kind of script that can easily be put to the screen.


Update : Again big movie news! Brent Weeks's Night Angle trilogy (I still haven't read it) was optioned for a movie (as seen at
The Mad Hatter's) and the project for Richard Morgan's Altered Carbon is still in progress (Pat post). This last one could be something great if they nail the right script, the book is incredible.


Finally, even more interestingly though, George R.R. Martin's A Game of Throne casting for the HBO series is going well. George posted on his Not a blog the first list of the chosen actors. I think that Sean Bean is a very good choice to play the part of Eddard Stark. From what I know so far, this should be something interesting to follow, I don't think it's not going to look like Legend of the Seeker (I don't really like the result of this....).

a Fantasy Reader All rights reserved © Blog Milk - Powered by Blogger